2011 - Eric Northman (True Blood)
2012 - Eric Northman (True Blood)
2013 - Eric Northman (True Blood)
2014 - Eric Northman (True Blood)
2015 - Ragnar Lothbrok (Vikings)
2016 - Luke Cage (Luke Cage)
2017 - Luke Cage (The Defenders)
2018 - Gadi Becker (The Little Drummer Girl)